Needlepointers
Look up through the tracery of the late winter trees. The Rio
Grande bosque has a surprise for you.
Like a spray of fruiting mistletoe, a dusky, dark sphere with white
highlights is clinging tight
to a topmost branch
A stealthy
skunk? A maverick monkey? A stout stoat? No, it’s a prickly
porcupine!
Noisy yet quiet, heavily armed yet vulnerable,
antisocial yet even-tempered and take-it-easy tolerant, this
nocturnal highliver is a salt-and-pepper paradox, a sweet-tart mix
of opposites. A porcupine may bumble and lumber on land, yet both
male and female are strong swimmers, swift and sure when paddling
across the river to snack on island salt cedar shoots.
Saber-clawed, porcupines may climb 60 feet high to feed far out on
cottonwood limbs, balancing 25 or more pounds on branches no thicker
than the width of a finger. In exchange for this high-wire habit,
they are prone to top-down falls, suffering injury and, not
infrequently, death.
Though rodents like rats, mice, squirrels, and
beavers, the porcupine is an oddball among kinfolk in the order
Rodentia. While most relatives live fast, die young, and leave a
multitude of offspring behind, the porcupine is a Methuselah among
rodents: some animals will succeed in gnawing through 18 long years
of life. Females devote seven months of each year to the production
of a single infant, one of the longest gestations in the animal
world, and will nurse their porcupet for another four months after
that.
Like the dark and light of their quilly, bristly,
furry coats, North American porcupines are marvels of contradictions
and contrasts. For the wildlife observer in the Rio Grande bosque,
they offer an extra lure: findability. Unlike the skittery lizard
who vanishes into leaf litter; unlike the rare bird that flies off
before binoculars can focus, find, and identify it, porcupines stay
put in their daytime resting trees. Unconcerned about a babble of
excited voices on the ground, a portly porcupine will gaze sleepily
at the forest of binoculars raised in her direction. Then she’ll
nod off for another nap.
Footing
It, High and Wide
Short limbs and a slow, flat-footed gait
notwithstanding, North American porcupines have come a long,
long way from their ancestral origins in South America when
prickly predecessors crossed the Panamanian land bridge in
the early Pliocene period three million years ago.
Traveling farther than fellow South American migrants the
opossum and the armadillo, North America’s only porcupine
species eventually reached Alaska and the tree line of the
High Arctic. Today, Erethison dorsatum is the
northernmost of the world’s 21, mostly tropical, porcupine
species.
The North American continent
south to Mexico and east to the Appalachians has provided a
forest commissary of hardwood and softwood trees for this
arboreal rodent to sample. Wielding naked, pebbly-textured,
tree-grasping paws that are nerved with a keen sense of
touch and armed with long claws that can grip into bark like
the grappling leg hooks of a telephone lineman, a hungry
porcupine scampers up, up, and away on a summer night,
slapping the bristles of his versatile, stabilizing tail
against a tree trunk to feed on all the tree has to offer:
buds, twigs, leaves, flowers, and fruits. (Porcupines
rarely drink in summer since vegetation provides all the
water they need.) Topmost resources exhausted, the climber
descends, coordinating claw holds and tail grips, down to
the ground to feast on juicy tree roots. With a little
luck, he might find some salt-rich animal bones nearby to
chew for a chaser. |
 |
For an animal that feeds on vegetation far out on shaky, brittle
branches, what goes up must come down ─ at times, breakbone hard
down. Although well adapted for the high life, porcupines are not
immune to impalement on their own quills following falls. (One
museum study of skeletons revealed that 30 % of the animals had
suffered fractures, many of which had healed, indicating post-fall
survival.) Evolution has given porcupines a remarkable trait that
has helped many rebound after a mishap: antibiotics in their
quills.
Those Agonizing, Mesmerizing, Fido-incising
Quills
With a body count of 30,000 quills sprouting
everywhere except belly, muzzle, and ears, the porcupine is a living
fortress and a spiked artillery attack unit. Quills are tools of
many uses ─ Swiss Army knives that support, protect, and defend
their owner. Conspicuously black with white tips, and containing a
fluorescent material to warn off nighttime predators, quills are
modified guard hairs. Each is from one half to four inches long and
has shingle-lapped barbs at the tip for easy entry. Once inside,
the barbs expand as muscles of the victim contract, pulling quills
deeper and deeper into the flesh; body heat increases air pressure
inside the quills, making them hard to extract. Quills on the back
of the porcupine’s club-like tail, its principal slap-propelled
shaft stabber,
are very special: they have a greasy coating that keeps them stiff
and rainproof while providing lubrication to burrow deep into the
victim. Moreover, these particular quills contain fatty acids that
inhibit the growth of six Gram-positive bacteria including those
that cause tetanus and gas gangrene, infections that could finish
off an unfortunate animal impaled on its own weaponry after a fall.
Though damaged and down on the ground, an immobile porcupine might
still be protected from a once-burned-twice-shy predator, mindful of
the quill’s pain potential; the wounded animal thereby would gain a
measure of recovery time along with aid from the quill’s antibiotic
component. (Porcupines will also use their incisors and formidable
four-fingered front paws to remove quills.)
Finally, porcupine quills contain a spongy material
that provides water-wing buoyancy for a plump animal clambering down
a riverbank and dogpaddling through the waves to an island food
source.
Predator Proof?
Hungry carnivores lurk in the hills, hollows,
and forests of the porcupine’s world. In the northern U.S., the
agile fisher has become a porcupine specialist, lunging in and out
to attack the rodent’s bare face; in the West, it’s the mountain
lion. One Nevada study showed that of 98 radio-collared porcupines,
95 of them had been killed when flipped over and rendered supine by
the big cat. In the Southwest, there are other predators ─ bobcats,
foxes, coyotes, and great-horned owls that score a rare kill.
Although a lucky hit to a vital organ can kill a predator, some will
tolerate the porcupine’s quill defense ─ and if infected, receive a
dose of antibiotic at the same time.
Although quills are the most famous weapon that this
generally peaceable vegetarian uses to deter enemies, a painful
tailslap is actually the act of a fighter with its back to the wall,
giving its final, and most pointed, warning.
A
naïve, hungry coyote is hunting at night. He spots something moving
down a tree. Although alerted to the black and white coloration on
the animal’s head and back, the coyote ignores the warning and
creeps closer. Next, he encounters an unfamiliar stop-and-start
rasping sound, an ominous clacking and chattering of teeth. If the
coyote persists, he’ll be overwhelmed by a goaty, powerful,
can’t-stand-it smell that the porcupine releases from the rosette, a
bare-skin area at the base of the tail. What’s next for this
predator? Likely, a muzzle-load of quills. He’s naïve no more.
And Baby Makes Three
When it comes to reproduction, the female
porcupine is a reticent rodent, unreceptive except for a
once-a-year, eight-to-twelve hour period when she’s in estrus. Does
anticipation of close, quilly contact keep male and female apart, as
many a wag has suggested? (“How do porcupines make love? Very
carefully!”) And what about discomfort for the female enduring the
birth of a quilly baby?
While the story of porcupine reproduction indeed has
its points of interest, fear of pain and impalement is not one of
them. First job for these solitary animals: find each other.
In early fall, before winter snows halt most
porcupine movement, males begin to expand their home ranges,
wandering far and wide with noses on alert. Females entice and
cooperate with high-pitched cries and urine-borne olfactory
signals. If she attracts more than one suitor, the contenders are
likely to have at it, shrieking and screaming, gouging out fur and
flesh with their hard, sharp, orange incisors, and flailing away
with tail slaps until the ground is boot-deep in quills. The
largest and heaviest male usually wins the day.
Then comes a weird, unexplained male behavior: he
hoses down the female with urine. If she’s not interested, she
shakes off the shower; if she likes his saucy attention, courtship
continues. The two rise up on their hind feet, whine, grunt, rub
noses, and embrace with gentle cuffing and paws placed on each
other’s shoulders. Then it’s down to the ground and down to
business.
The female elevates her hind quarters and swings her
dangerous tail out of the way. After copulation, a vaginal plug
forms, perhaps to bar the door for other hose-happy males. After
210 days of gestation, a one-pound baby is born, covered in fur
along with short, soft quills, and wrapped in its amnion sac.
Quills harden in a few hours; although the precocious porcupet can
walk and climb trees within days of birth, it will nurse and then
sample vegetation beside its mother for up to five months, a lengthy
dependency that some attribute to the low nutritive value of the
porcupine’s leafeater’s diet.
sunny, blustery morning in January. Students from the Bosque
School mill along a forest trail behind their North Valley campus,
nudging, chatting, and catching up on news, views, and rendezvous.
At the silent ring of an unseen bell, all eyes and ears turn to
science teacher Dan Shaw.
“OK, I need four kids to collect sticks straight as
possible, four more to carry the animal back from the tree to here,
and one to give the injection,” declared Shaw.
During the previous night, a male porcupine, high in
a slender mulberry tree, had caught the scent of salted apples and
peanut butter. Yes! Here was a welcome change from his dreary
winter survival diet of tree cambium, the nutrient-poor inner bark
he’d been chewing from the mulberry’s upper branches. Descending
carefully, the hungry animal found his treat ─ but it was inside a
Havahart® catch-and-release trap that Shaw had set and baited the
night before. The porcupine’s fair deal: a tasty meal in exchange
for a quick weigh-in and a veterinary once-over by caring examiners.
Thorny
Fieldwork
In 2008, Shaw and
his students entered the sixth year of the school’s Bosque
Porcupine Project, a long-term study seeking to provide
basic data and natural history information about porcupines
in the Middle Rio Grande Valley and document their effect on
cottonwoods and other components of the forest ecosystem.
Upperclass students in Shaw’s Wildlife Biology and
Conservation class have learned how to process the captured
animals, while his sixth graders assist and monitor the
work.
To complement twelve
years of data derived from Bosque Ecosystem Monitoring
Program studies, an inter-agency research effort that
continues to use students and teachers to monitor production
and consumption of organic matter and nutrients in the
riparian forest (bosqueschool.org/bemp.htm), Shaw has
focused his porcupine surveys on areas surrounding eleven of
BEMP’s 25 sites. His prime target: two sites of five acres
each within a 113-acre stretch between Montaño Bouldevard
and the Oxbow, east of the school’s campus.
Working intensively in fall and winter months, Shaw and his
student crew, along with veterinarian Susan Dicks, (“We
never handle porcupines unless a vet is present,” noted
Shaw) have examined some 20 animals since 2003, with a
capture rate of about 50% of traps set. Following sedation,
the porcupines are implanted with microchips for later
identification. Each animal receives a wear-away radio
collar with a six-month battery and a six-digit frequency
number that trackers can capture on one of the school’s
three antennas. |

Hefty Handiwork
Photo: Dan Shaw |
Quill Drill
With all equipment on hand and all hands on
deck, the morning’s field work began. After a short walk through
the bosque, the porcupine hunters reached the trap Shaw had set at
the base of the mulberry tree: a square frame of chicken wire four
feet high with a two-foot band inside and a dark tarp over the top.
Arranging the straight sticks collected by his students, Shaw
carefully funneled the porcupine out of the trap and into a cage for
transport to the animal’s outdoor exam room: the rear of a truck,
waiting back on the trail. Once there, veterinarian Dicks took
charge.
First weighing the animal to calibrate the correct
drug dosage (l1.5 kg or about 23 pounds indicating .4 ml/kg ─ “a
whopper dose,” commented Dr. Dicks, “more than dogs and wolves
get”), she then discussed and demonstrated all phases of the
injection process for the students: how to draw the drug up without
getting air in the syringe; how to find a patch of skin on the
porcupine’s rump (“Remember, the tail and the mouth are your danger
zones”); and how to avoid hitting a blood vessel which would sedate
the animal too quickly. “Go in at an angle,” she advised her
volunteer injector, junior Addy Gordon, who had pulled on
super-heavy gloves, “and steady the needle with your left hand.”
Fifteen minutes later, the patient was dozing and
stretched out on his belly, heart rate and pulse checked and
declared normal. A recaptured male wearing a radio collar, he was
over three years old, down about two pounds from his previous
weigh-in last year. He also had a nasty smell ─ an infection
revealed when his inch-wide collar was removed. Quickly, the team
switched from fieldwork science to Plan B: veterinary care.
After clipping the area and swabbing it clean, Dr.
Dicks applied a triple antibiotic ointment to the laceration. “Our
priorities are always human safety, animal welfare, and scientific
inquiry in that order,” noted Shaw, adding “today is only the second
time in all these years that the radio collar has caused trouble.”
Carried back to the forest and released at the base
of his mulberry feeding tree, the now collarless porcupine received
his second prick of the morning: a shot to reverse the sedative.
Four minutes later, he was on his feet. Urged on by a shoe nudge
from Shaw, he slapped his armored tail sleepily back and forth,
offering his indignant opinion of the day’s events and providing a
clear crescendo to end them.
Animal work
completed, Shaw took a moment to talk about the porcupine project,
with additional research data supplied by senior student Katie
Elder.
Scanimals
Of the twenty porcupines caught since 2003,
reported the investigators, tooth eruptions indicated that most
animals were over two years old. Ten were males, eight were
females, and two were unsexed; weights ranged from 2.5 kg to 9.5 kg
with some of the females pregnant. Lice infestations, which some
scientists believe may be beneficial to the host by cleaning away
excess fur-clotting grease and dead skin cells, ranged from heavy to
none at all.
Gauging tree preferences, a porcupine at rest is
almost always a provincial, parked in a cottonwood, said Shaw. When
hungry, he becomes a cosmopolitan. “We’ve found that porcupines in
our bosque will feed on just about any woody stem they can grab,” he
said. “That includes mature cottonwoods, New Mexico olives, coyote
willow and Gooding’s willow, along with exotic Russian olive,
mulberry, Siberian elm, tree of heaven (ailanthus), and tamarisk or
salt cedar.” As for the porcupine’s effect on the native plant
community, neither Shaw nor Elder see cause for alarm. Although
porcupines are considered bark-stripping, tree-killing pests in many
parts of their North American range, “bosque porcupines don’t girdle
our cottonwoods like they do Russian olives,” Shaw noted. “The
bark’s too tough. Although he and Elder have seen invasive salt
cedar and Russian olive trees nearly bark-naked, these chewed up
invasive exotics will still regenerate from stumps, Shaw added.
During winter-to-spring river island surveys that Shaw and his
students have conducted by canoe, they’ve noted many signs of
porcupine excavation ─ salt cedar stems dug up by these
river-swimming, salt-loving rodents. “Porcupines make use of the
islands along with beavers and rare tawny-bellied cotton rats,” Shaw
said, apparently an amicable arrangement for all.
Where
in the bosque do porcupines hang out?
“We find animals in all stretches of the
bosque with extensive winter overlap of individual home ranges,”
Shaw answered. “The acreage behind our school, with its mature
cottonwoods and full understory of deep brush piles, has one of the
densest populations with about one animal every eight to ten acres
compared to one every 16 to 25 acres in other parts of the bosque
with less favorable habitat.” Porcupines use dens, too, he
continued ─ abandoned beaver dens, culverts, and deep brush piles,
but they don’t overwinter in them. “We regularly see porcupines out
during really cold weather,” he remarked. “In fact, during one
six-week period in late December 2006 that included a snow and ice
storm, one female with a radio collar was content to stay put in her
cottonwood feeding tree. Later, she moved north to Montaño,” he
continued, “then came back to the same tree.”
What
about predators in the bosque?
With no mountain lions around, humans and
their cars are the main cause of death here, noted Shaw. Coyotes
and bobcats will take some, but great-horned owls may be wary.
“I’ve seen porcupines high up in the same trees with the owls,” he
said.
Reaping Rodent Rewards
As for the mechanics of capture and handling,
Shaw’s project is the first to test the efficacy of the sedative
Domitor® and its reversal agent Antisedan® on porcupines with no
adverse reactions noted. In February, students Elder and Anna
Pérez-Umphry won the best student poster award for their drug
research display presented at the annual joint meeting of the New
Mexico and Arizona chapters of the Wildlife Society and the American
Fisheries Society. Competitors for the award were university
undergraduates and graduate students, noted Shaw. “I’m very proud
of Katie and Anna.”
In 2008, The Bosque School’s porcupine project
continues on a roll and is ripe for expansion. Next step:
identifying relationships among animals. “As soon as we have enough
hair and quill samples, we plan to do DNA analysis on them via
electrophoresis,” said Shaw. “Probably next year. We also want to
look at where the animals move in summer.” Publication of project
results is also likely next year, added Elder.
“Porcupines are great ambassadors for kids,” Shaw
remarked. “They are adapting and doing well in an urban habitat,
making a living and getting their needs met among us, right here,”
he noted. “Also, porcupines are idiosyncratic with their quills,
their double-digit life spans, and their sloth-like behavior,” he
continued. Observable and interesting for student-scientists and
Nature Center observers alike, “they build a connection to the
wild.”
Look up into
the tracery of the late winter trees.
Sources:
Alaska Department of Fish & Game. Porcupine.
http://www.adfg.state.ak.us/pubs/notebook/smgame; Katie
Elder and Anna Pérez-Umphry. 2008. Poster Exhibit: North American
porcupine (Erethizon dorsatum): live capture technique and
the effectiveness of using the sedative medetomidine
hydrochloride (Domitor®) and the antagonist atipamezole
hydrochloride (Antisedan®) to facilitate handling; New Mexico
Department of Game and Fish. Wildlife notes: porcupine Erithison
dorsatum. www/wildlife.state.nm.us/education/wildlife_notes/documents/porcupine.pdf;
North American Porcupine (Erethizon dorsatum) research
and bosque porcupine project – research plan.
http://www.bosqueschool.org/bemp.porcupine.htm; Ronald Nowak
and John Paradiso. Walker’s mammals of the world, 4th
ed. 1983. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins Press; Uldis Roze. 1989.
The North American porcupine. Washington, D.C.: Smithsonian Press;
Uldis Roze. 2006. “Smart weapons.” Natural History 115 (2)
48-53; Katie Elder; Dan Shaw.